Txtng is Killing Language: A Review of John McWhorter’s Talk

726 words, 2 pages, 4 min read
Table of content

In recent years, the debate around texting and its impact on language has become increasingly prominent, especially with the rapid rise of mobile communication. John McWhorter, a linguist and professor at Columbia University, dives into this topic in his engaging talk “Txtng is Killing Language,” which challenges the conventional belief that texting is damaging our linguistic skills. Instead, he presents a nuanced view that emphasizes the complexity and evolution of language in the digital age.

The Evolution of Language

To understand McWhorter’s perspective, it’s essential to acknowledge that language is not static; it evolves over time. Historically, each significant shift in communication—whether it was the advent of the printing press or the introduction of telephones—has sparked concerns about how these changes would affect language. McWhorter points out that similar fears accompanied every technological advance. However, rather than eroding linguistic skills, these innovations often enriched them by providing new forms of expression.

In his talk, McWhorter emphasizes that texting should be viewed as an extension of our linguistic repertoire rather than a detriment to it. Texting is not simply about conveying information; it’s also about expressing emotions and building social connections. The use of abbreviations, acronyms, and emojis serves as a modern way for individuals to communicate nuances that might be lost in more traditional forms of writing.

Texting as a New Dialect

One fascinating point McWhorter makes is that texting can be seen as a new dialect—a form of language unique to digital communication. This dialect has its own rules and conventions which are distinct from formal writing or spoken language. For instance, when people text “LOL” or use various emoji combinations to convey laughter or affection, they are utilizing a set of symbols that have developed their own meanings within this context.

This notion challenges the stigma attached to texting as being inferior or simplistic compared to standard written English. In reality, it demonstrates creativity and adaptability in language usage. Young people are not abandoning proper grammar; instead, they are learning to navigate multiple linguistic landscapes simultaneously—a skill that’s increasingly vital in today’s interconnected world.

The Role of Context

A crucial aspect of McWhorter’s argument revolves around context. He stresses that effective communication hinges on understanding when different forms of language are appropriate. Just like one would adjust their speech depending on whether they’re chatting with friends at a cafe or presenting in front of an audience at work, texting fits into this broader spectrum of communication styles.

Moreover, McWhorter highlights how many individuals can seamlessly switch between formal writing and informal texting without losing clarity or effectiveness—a skill known as code-switching. This flexibility showcases cognitive sophistication rather than decline; it illustrates how younger generations are mastering diverse modes of expression suited for varying contexts.

The Future: Embracing Change

As technology continues to evolve rapidly—think social media platforms like Twitter or TikTok—the way we communicate will inevitably change alongside it. Rather than fearing these changes as threats to our cherished linguistic traditions, McWhorter encourages us to embrace them as opportunities for growth and innovation within our languages.

This perspective invites us all—including educators—to reconsider our approach toward teaching language arts. Instead of viewing texts from students through a lens tainted by preconceived notions about “proper” English usage (often heavily influenced by traditional academic standards), we might benefit from encouraging students’ creativity within their chosen forms—texting included.

A Call for Understanding

Ultimately, John McWhorter’s talk serves not just as an insightful analysis but also as a rallying cry for understanding—and even celebrating—the ways in which technology shapes our communication landscape today. The fear-mongering narrative surrounding texting may overlook essential truths about human adaptability; after all—it’s been part and parcel throughout history! As society continues navigating this ever-evolving landscape filled with myriad expressions through screens large and small alike—we owe ourselves an open mind towards appreciating what comes next!

In conclusion: let’s take note from linguists like McWhorter who remind us there’s room enough for both innovation AND tradition within languages moving forward!

  • McWhorter J.H., "Txtng: The Gr8 Deb8", 2011.
  • Cristal D., "Language Death", 2000.
  • Lynch M., "The Disruption Of Language: How Tech Affects Communication", 2021.
  • Meyer C.F., "English Corpus Linguistics: An Introduction", 2002.
  • Snyder I., "Teaching Literacy In The Digital Age", 2010.

Learn the cost and time for your paper

1 page (275 words)
Deadline in: 0 days

No need to pay just yet!

Related Essays
Picture of Sophia Hale
Sophia Hale

This essay was reviewed by